Unless you live in a cave (or unless you are a very well-informed cave-dweller) then you know about
Twilight. These books have become a huge sensation, reminiscent of the Harry Potter Series. There are four books in total:
Twilight, New Moon, Eclipse, and
Breaking Dawn. And while I have not read all four, I have read the first one and am now stuck with the question: WHAT'S THE BIG DEAL?!
At the risk of offending anyone who likes the book, I have a few issues to discuss.
- The first two-hundred pages of the book can be summarized in one sentence. "Bella moves to a new town and meets a very good looking boy named Edward, who acts very strangely around her, leading her to fear that Edward dislikes her." NO JOKE! It takes two-hundred pages to say this! The last one-hundred pages are decent - they tell about how this super-vampire (he's a "tracker" so watch out!) tries to eat Bella and fails - but a three hundred page book should have more than one hundred pages of story!
- This book was written for middle school girls, but it sounds like it was written by a middle school girl. Here is a typical scene:
"Edward," she said, staring up into his too-perfect eyes. "Promise me you'll never leave."
Edward grimaced and said, dangerously, "I shouldn't be here. I shouldn't be talking to you. This is too dangerous." He smiled dazzlingly. "I would never forgive myself if something happened to you," he said threateningly.
She gazed longingly at his body; he was like a greek god. "But I love you," she said, enigmatically.
He didn't answer, he just got in his too-perfect Volvo and drove away at a speed of 200 mph.
Bella flushed with rage. She couldn't speak. She shook her hands angrily. "I love you," she said tenderly as he drove away. "And I always will," she said ominously. "Until the day I die," she said, even more ominously than before.
My point is this - I wouldn't be suprised if Cormac McCarthy
ate a bowl of alphabet soup and barfed up writing better than this! And I'm not a book-snob. I loved Harry Potter. I liked the Da Vinci Code. I'm not some guy who only likes James Joyce (pictured with eye-patch). But I have my standards and Twilight is almost unreadable.
3. I can't believe Edward doesn't bite her and turn her into a vampire like she wants him too. That was extremely lame and was only done so that she could have a reason to keep writing books and making more money. I don't have a problem with her making money, but when she RUINS her story just to cash in on the franchise a little more, I think there's a problem. (Spoiler Alert).
SO...I'd be happy to hear from any fans of Twilight who can tell me why I'm wrong. Maybe the next books are better; maybe they are "too-perfect" (Stephanie Meyer's favorite vacuous adjective). But I just don't see what the fuss is about.
Read more...